
Last reviewed: 1 November 2026. This article contains affiliate links*
Xero vs Sage, in short: for a small UK limited company or any business with staff, we would choose Xero over Sage: its Grow plan (£39) includes payroll for one person, while Sage charges for payroll on top of every plan. Sage is the better buy for sole traders who are not VAT-registered, thanks to a free plan and a £7 tier, and for businesses whose accountant or bookkeeper already works in Sage. Choose Xero if you employ people or plan to grow; choose Sage if you want the lowest cost as a one-person, non-VAT business.
Quick verdict
- Overall: Xero. It was our favourite overall when we trialled the main UK packages.
- Cheapest: Sage, with Sole Trader Free (£0) for non-VAT sole traders sending up to 5 invoices a month.
- Employers: Xero, with payroll included from Grow.
- Multi-currency: close. Xero Comprehensive is £55, Sage Plus is £59.
New customers only. Terms apply. We may earn a commission if you sign up.
Xero or Sage by type of business
Start here if you know what kind of business you run. The plan named is the one we would expect most businesses of that type to need.
| Your business | Xero plan | Sage plan | Our pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| New sole trader, not VAT-registered, few invoices | Simple, £7 | Sole Trader Free, £0 | Sage |
| VAT-registered sole trader or freelancer | Ignite, £18 (20 invoices, 10 bills) | Start, £20 | Sage if you invoice often; Xero if you will add payroll soon |
| Limited company paying one director | Grow, £39 (payroll for 1) | Standard, £43 plus payroll add-on | Xero |
| Employer with up to 5 staff | Comprehensive, £55 (payroll for 5) | Standard or Plus plus payroll add-on | Xero |
| Trading in foreign currencies | Comprehensive, £55 | Plus, £59 | Xero, narrowly |
Xero vs Sage side by side
Sage prices were correct at the time of checking; confirm them on Sage’s site, as its plans and offers change during the year.
| Xero | Sage Accounting | |
|---|---|---|
| Plans and UK prices (per month, ex VAT) | Simple £7, Ignite £18, Grow £39, Comprehensive £55, Ultimate £70 | Sole Trader Free £0, Sole Trader £7, Start £20, Standard £43, Plus £59 |
| Users | No general user limit stated on the pricing page | Sage’s FAQ says it supports unlimited users; confirm for your plan |
| Payroll | Included: 1 person on Grow, 5 on Comprehensive, 10 on Ultimate; optional on Ignite | Add-on (Sage quotes from £8 a month for up to 5 employees) |
| VAT and MTD | VAT returns to HMRC; MTD for Income Tax ready | MTD for VAT on VAT-capable plans; sole trader plans aimed at MTD for Income Tax |
| Bank feeds | Yes; auto-reconcile from Grow | Yes |
| Multi-currency | Comprehensive and Ultimate | Plus only |
| Free trial or plan | Free trial; no free plan | Free plan for non-VAT sole traders; trial or introductory offer on paid plans |
| Mobile app | Yes | iOS and Android |
Sage has been selling accounting software to UK businesses for decades, and plenty of bookkeepers learned on its desktop products. Xero arrived as a cloud-only product and built its following among accountants who wanted clients online. Today both are cloud apps with bank feeds, invoicing and MTD filing, so the history matters less than it used to. What still differs is how each one prices payroll, how far the cheapest plans stretch and which one your accountant prefers.
Price
Sage starts lower. Its free plan and £7 Sole Trader tier undercut everything Xero sells except Simple, which matches it at £7. For a VAT-registered business the entry points are close: Xero Ignite at £18 against Sage Start at £20, though Ignite’s limits of 20 invoices and 10 bills mean busier traders may prefer Sage Start.
Higher up, Xero becomes the better value because payroll is bundled. Xero Grow at £39 includes one person on payroll; Sage Standard is £43 before you add payroll. Through our links, new customers get 80% off Xero for the first 6 months or 90% off Sage for the first 6 months, then standard prices apply; our Sage discount page has the full Sage terms. For more low-cost options, see our cheapest accounting software guide.
Winner: Sage for one-person businesses; Xero once there is payroll.
New customers only. Terms apply. We may earn a commission if you sign up.
Xero vs Sage: what you pay over two years
The two offers through our links are unusually close: 80% off Xero for 6 months and 90% off Sage for 6 months. That makes year one almost level plan for plan, so the real difference shows up in year two and in payroll. These figures assume your plan is eligible for the offer and exclude VAT; Sage prices are as at the time of checking.
| Xero plan | Xero: year 1 / year 2 | Sage plan | Sage: year 1 / year 2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple (£7) | £50.40 / £84 | Sole Trader (£7) | £46.20 / £84 |
| Ignite (£18) | £129.60 / £216 | Start (£20) | £132 / £240 |
| Grow (£39, payroll for 1) | £280.80 / £468 | Standard (£43) plus payroll from £8 | £379.80 / £612 |
| Comprehensive (£55, payroll for 5) | £396 / £660 | Plus (£59) plus payroll from £8 | £485.40 / £804 |
Without payroll, the two cost almost the same at every level, and Sage keeps the advantage at the very bottom with Sole Trader Free at £0. Once payroll is involved, Xero pulls ahead on these pairings by about £90 to £100 in year one and £144 in year two, because its payroll is part of the plan price.
Sole traders: the cheapest sensible route on each
Sole traders are where Sage is most competitive, so it is worth walking through the options by size:
- Not VAT registered, up to 5 sales invoices a month: Sage Sole Trader Free costs nothing. Xero has no free plan; its cheapest is Simple at £7, whose limits you should confirm on Xero’s site.
- Not VAT registered, busier: Sage Sole Trader at £7 or Xero Ignite at £18, which allows 20 invoices and 10 bills a month.
- VAT registered: Xero Ignite (£18) against Sage Start (£20). Xero’s caps make Sage Start the better fit if you send more than 20 invoices a month; above that on Xero you need Grow at £39.
- Heading into MTD for Income Tax: if your qualifying income is over £30,000 (and not over £50,000), you join from 6 April 2027. Both providers describe their sole trader options as suitable, but check your plan on HMRC’s software finder.
For a wider view across all five providers, our guide to the best accounting software for sole traders ranks the options.
Ease of use
Sage Accounting is simple and uses traditional UK bookkeeping language, which helps if you have used Sage before. Xero’s bank reconciliation screen is, in our opinion, the best in the market for clearing transactions quickly, and its dashboard gives a clear view of cash in and out. Beginners will cope with either; we think Xero rewards regular users more.
Winner: Xero, slightly, for day-to-day bookkeeping.
Features
Xero’s plans list cash flow forecasts (30 days on Ignite, rising to 180 on Ultimate), automatic bill entry from Grow, and projects on Ultimate. Sage adds photo capture of receipts and invoices on Standard, and multi-currency with inventory management on Plus. If you hold stock, Sage Plus includes inventory management, which Xero’s core plans do not highlight. If you employ people, Xero’s bundled payroll is the bigger feature.
Winner: Xero for service businesses and employers; Sage Plus for small product businesses wanting stock in the same package.
New customers only. Terms apply. We may earn a commission if you sign up.
Payroll costs in more detail
Xero includes payroll for 1 person on Grow, 5 on Comprehensive and 10 on Ultimate, and charges £1.50 a month for each extra person (£1 on Ultimate). On Ignite, payroll is optional at £1.50 per person. Sage sells payroll as an add-on, quoted from £8 a month for up to 5 employees.
That means the cheapest Sage route for an employer depends on which plan the add-on can be used with. If it works with Start for your business, Start plus payroll from £8 comes to about £28 a month, which undercuts Xero Grow at £39. On Standard, the total is about £51, and Xero Grow is cheaper. Ask Sage which plans its payroll add-on covers, and price your own headcount, before you rely on either figure.
Making Tax Digital
Both file VAT returns under MTD for VAT, which has covered every VAT-registered business since April 2022. For MTD for Income Tax, Xero lists its plans as ready and Sage’s sole trader plans are designed for it. The rules: if your qualifying income (gross self-employment and property income) was over £50,000, you should have started on 6 April 2026; over £30,000 you start on 6 April 2027; over £20,000 on 6 April 2028. You send quarterly updates through your software and submit a tax return by 31 January. Partnerships will join later, with no date set yet, and some people, such as the digitally excluded, can be exempt. There is no confirmed MTD requirement for Corporation Tax.
Our Making Tax Digital explainer covers the detail, and our MTD preparation guide lists the steps before your start date.
Winner: a draw. Both cover VAT and Income Tax; choose on price and payroll instead.
Support and accountants
Both are well known among UK accountants. Sage has the longer history with traditional practices; Xero is very common among firms that work mainly in the cloud. Both offer online help and in-app support, with channels varying by plan. The practical test is simple: ask your accountant which they use, because working in the same system usually means fewer questions at year-end.
Winner: a draw, decided in practice by your accountant.
Integrations
Xero’s app marketplace is very large and covers most ecommerce, payments, CRM and expense tools a small business would use. Sage also connects to common UK tools. If you rely on a niche app, check its integrations list first; otherwise, we think Xero’s marketplace gives more choice.
Winner: Xero.
Five things to check before choosing
- Your accountant’s system. Both are widely used in the UK, so this often settles it.
- Your VAT position. Sage Sole Trader Free is for non-VAT businesses only; both providers file MTD VAT returns on their VAT-capable plans.
- Your monthly invoice and bill volumes. Xero Ignite stops at 20 invoices and 10 bills a month, and Sage Sole Trader Free at 5 sales invoices.
- Whether you hold stock. Sage Plus includes inventory management; inventory is not listed on Xero’s UK plans, so Xero users add a stock app.
- How many people you pay. Price Xero’s per-person payroll against Sage’s add-on for your real headcount.
Switching between Xero and Sage
If you are already on one and tempted by the other, time the move for a year-end or the end of a VAT quarter so no period is split across two systems. Export your contacts, opening balances and outstanding invoices, and ask your accountant whether they will handle the conversion. Keep read-only access to the old system, or a full export, for as long as you must keep records: GOV.UK says at least 5 years after the 31 January submission deadline for sole traders, and 6 years from the end of the financial year for limited companies.
Honest cons
Xero
- No free plan, and Ignite caps you at 20 invoices and 10 bills.
- Prices went up from 1 September 2026.
- Projects only on Ultimate; expense claims charged per extra user.
Sage Accounting
- Payroll is an add-on on every plan.
- The free plan is for non-VAT sole traders with up to 5 sales invoices a month.
- Multi-currency and inventory are only on Plus.
- Standard costs more than double Start.
My take: I trialled both for a limited company. Xero took me about 5 minutes to set up, Sage about 10, and Xero gave me the stronger overall impression: straightforward sign-up, a clear interface and good value. Sage covers the core accounting jobs and many accountants use it, but it did not give me a compelling enough reason to choose it over Xero. If your accountant works in Sage, that can tip the balance. (Joe P.)
Xero vs Sage: our verdict
Our Xero vs Sage verdict: Xero is our pick for most small UK businesses, and particularly for limited companies and employers, because payroll is included and it scales without changing systems. Sage is the sensible choice for a sole trader who is not VAT-registered and wants to pay as little as possible, and for anyone whose accountant works in Sage. If you are also weighing QuickBooks, our Xero vs QuickBooks and Sage vs QuickBooks comparisons cover it.
Read our full Xero review and Sage Accounting review, or see our best accounting software picks.
How we compared them
We signed up for and trialled Xero, QuickBooks, Sage, FreeAgent and Zoho Books ourselves. Xero was our favourite overall, with FreeAgent a close second. For this Xero vs Sage comparison, Xero details come from its UK pricing page and Sage prices from startups.co.uk (updated 1 September 2026), because Sage’s pricing page did not load for us. MTD rules were checked against GOV.UK.
Xero vs Sage FAQs
Is Sage cheaper than Xero?
At the bottom of the range, yes: Sage has a free plan for non-VAT sole traders, and its £7 Sole Trader plan matches Xero Simple. Once you need payroll, Xero is usually cheaper because Grow (£39) includes one person while Sage charges for payroll on top.
Xero vs Sage: which is cheaper over two years?
Without payroll they are close: for example Xero Ignite costs £129.60 then £216 with our offer, against £132 then £240 for Sage Start. With payroll, Xero is usually cheaper because Grow includes 1 person, while Sage charges for payroll on top.
Does Xero include payroll?
Yes, from Grow upwards: 1 person on Grow, 5 on Comprehensive and 10 on Ultimate, with extra people charged per head. On Ignite payroll is optional at extra cost.
Which is better for MTD for Income Tax?
Both are suitable. Xero lists its plans as MTD for Income Tax ready and Sage’s sole trader plans are built for it. Check HMRC’s software finder for your income types, especially if you also have property income.
Is there MTD for Corporation Tax?
There is no confirmed MTD mandate for Corporation Tax. Limited companies that are VAT-registered must follow MTD for VAT, which both Xero and Sage support.
Do accountants prefer Xero or Sage?
It depends on the practice. Sage is long established with traditional UK firms and Xero is common among cloud-focused firms. Ask yours before choosing.
Sage vs Xero for a business that holds stock?
Sage Plus (£59) includes inventory management. Inventory is not listed on Xero’s UK plans, so you would add a stock app from Xero’s marketplace. If you also run payroll, compare the total cost of each set-up.
Can I start on Sage’s free plan and move to Xero later?
Yes. You can start on Sage Sole Trader Free and move when you register for VAT or take on staff. Make the switch at the end of a VAT quarter or tax year, bring across your contacts and opening balances, and keep your old records for as long as GOV.UK requires.
Sources
- Xero UK pricing and plans
- Sage Accounting UK
- GOV.UK: when you need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax
- GOV.UK: find software compatible with MTD for Income Tax
Next step: read our Xero discount page for how the 80% off offer works, or visit our Sage discount page for the full terms of Sage’s 90% off offer.
New customers only. Terms apply. We may earn a commission if you sign up.
* Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you, and this never changes our ratings or rankings. Offers are for new customers only, are set by the provider and can change or end at any time, so check the terms before you sign up. Prices exclude VAT and were checked on 1 November 2026. Accounting Software Deals is independent and is not endorsed by any software provider. This page is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Read how we review and our affiliate disclosure.
